Mads Johnsen

Ask candidates to solve a current business challenge

I’ve found candidate presentations to be one of the best signals when hiring Product Managers and Designers and I have enforced them at all levels at the organizations I’ve led. 

When done well, presentations can yield a very accurate picture of a candidate’s problem-solving, presentation, and facilitation skills – three of the most critical skills in product. Candidates tend to perform exceptionally well or very poorly, and the hiring team often leaves with a largely aligned perspective on the candidate.

Over time, I’ve refined a straightforward process for candidate presentations –

Typically, the prompt looks something like this:

The candidate presentation is an important part of our hiring process. It gives you an opportunity to highlight your unique experiences and why you’re an excellent fit for the position. 

Brief bio (5 min): Tell us about yourself and why you are interested in [company]

Discussion Prompt (25 min): Our company is currently facing [a challenge], How might we further develop [our product] to solve this problem

Discussion (30 min): As you’re planning your presentation, leave about 30 min for Q&A at the end of the presentation.

The allotted time above is guidance, we look to you to manage time during discussion. The discussion will be attended by: [person 1, title], [person 2, title], [person 3, title]

If you have any questions, don’t hesitate to reach out to [recruiter] or [hiring manager]

Over the years, I’ve also developed a few best practices that I find yield much better discussions:

The skills tested in candidate presentations are highly relevant for on-the-job performance of a PM: Do they prepare well, think well on their feet, and facilitate a productive discussion? It's one of the best assessment instruments available—don’t skip it!